[Gc] Feature Request: Nearly-precise stack tracing
zach.saw at gmail.com
Thu Nov 1 16:02:24 PST 2012
I'd like to request a new feature for the GC.
This is a feature that would be useful to implement a nearly precise stack
trace. Using this, we do not have to trace CPU registers for possible
Note that I've implemented this for my own nearly precise GC a few years ago
but unfortunately I've only coded it for bcc32 and x86 -- it's therefore not
portable. In my experience (my GC runs 24-7 in a production environment), the
nearly-precise stack tracing method is a lot better at not retaining out of
scope pointers than the conservative one employed by BoehmGC. Out of scope
pointers are extremely rare compared to BoehmGC especially for C++. By out of
scope pointers, I mean pointers that linger in the stack and have not been
overridden by other info but is already out of scope (e.g. a function call that
declares a char array but never uses it).
Here's what needs to be done for stack tracing:
1) Don't trace CPU registers
2) Tracing stack: treat pointers as possibly valid only if the next GC_word is
equals to a magic number (choose an arbitrary number - preferably one that ends
with an odd number to ensure it won't traced as another pointer)
3) When allocating GC memory, the memory will never get garbage collected
during the sweep phase, *unless* we tell the GC that it's now ready to be
collected when untraceable. I haven't looked into your GC code yet but in my
own implementation, it's merely a single bit in the GC memory block descriptor.
These tweaks should only be enabled via
We also want to be able to tell the GC what that magic number is (e.g.
GC_set_nearly_precise_stack_trace_magic_number) and another function for
setting ready-to-be-swept flag --
These features, combined with the stack unwinding of C++ allows us to achieve
nearly-precise stack tracing.
More information about the Gc